Our take

Stags' Leap Winery Merlot Napa Valley Red Wine

GSW Score81/ 100

Shoppers are split on it. A mechanical score from 1 shopper rating on the store listing, checked Aug 12, 2026. It sits in the top 97% of the 514 wines we have scored, measured against the shelf on Sep 16, 2026. How we score

Style
Red wine
Size
750 ml
Grape
Merlot
Region
Napa Valley
Shelf barcode
0089819044412
Stags' Leap Winery Merlot Napa Valley Red Wine bottle
Vendor listing image · stored in the Grocery Store Wine image archive

Our take

What we make of this bottle

Merlot is a red grape that can stand as a complete wine on its own or soften a Cabernet-led blend. It generally ripens earlier than Cabernet Sauvignon and often carries a rounder structure. Regional guides describe plum and other dark fruit in it, with less forceful tannin than Cabernet Sauvignon in many examples. 1 shoppers have rated it, averaging 2 out of five, which lands well below the 4.71 median for our list, but a sample that small cannot carry real weight.

This wine comes from Napa Valley, a wine region only about thirty miles long that has been federally recognized since 1981. In our September 2026 checks, prices fell between $38.99 and $47.99. Stags' Leap Winery says on its own site that grapes were first planted on its Napa Valley property in 1872, and that Carl Doumani, then the owner, sold the estate in 1996 to Beringer, now part of Treasury Wine Estates.

Stags' Leap Winery's own listings for its two most recent Napa Valley Merlot vintages describe a wine built mostly from Merlot, rounded out with Malbec and a small amount of Petite Sirah, sourced mainly from the cooler, southerly Oak Knoll district with additional fruit from Oakville and the Stags Leap District. Both vintages spent roughly a year and a half aging in French oak, and both drew a 95-point score from the critic James Suckling, who called the more recent release “lush, fruit-driven and perfumed.”

Our call: this suits a shopper who trusts the producer's own account and a critic's backing; Stags' Leap sources the fruit from Oak Knoll and ages it about a year and a half in French oak, and a 95-point score from James Suckling has followed the wine's recent vintages. Pass if you weight shopper opinion heavily: the one rating on our record is a low score from a single shopper, and one score cannot settle which read is right.

More from the desk.

Related bottles with a written overview and a public evidence file.

The prices we checked

Dated store checks, not a promise about your store.

The regular price can vary by store and date.

From the producer

History & ownership (Stags' Leap Winery)

Stags' Leap Winery says on its own site that grapes were first planted on its Napa Valley property in 1872, and that owner Carl Doumani sold the estate in 1996 to Beringer, which is now part of Treasury Wine Estates.

Research status

What we are still checking

Our overview above draws on the dated store feed, shopper ratings, our region and grape research, and any sourced producer facts. We are still working to confirm the current release, the full producer record, and the bottle itself, and we update this page as we learn more.

Region guideNapa Valley

A little background helps this bottle make sense.

Getting to know Napa Valley.

Napa Valley is only about 30 miles long, yet its floor, hillsides and mountain sites differ sharply. The valley name establishes origin, while a nested AVA or vineyard gives a closer reading of place.

The place

What the name means

Napa Valley has been a federally recognized American Viticultural Area since 1981. Seventeen smaller AVAs now sit within its boundary.

Weather

How grapes grow here

The valley has a dry Mediterranean climate. San Pablo Bay cools the south, summer afternoons grow warmer toward the north, and fog lowers overnight temperatures across much of the valley.

Soil

What lies under the vines

Volcanic, marine and river activity created unusually varied ground. Napa Valley Vintners reports half of the world's twelve soil orders and 33 soil series within the region.

How large the region is

Land under cultivation
47,216 acres, or 19,108 hectares, are reported under cultivation.
Nested AVAs
17 approved AVAs sit within the Napa Valley AVA.

Places within the region

Valley floor
Oakville, Rutherford, St. Helena and Yountville are among the nested floor and benchland AVAs.
Hills and edges
Atlas Peak, Howell Mountain, Mount Veeder and Los Carneros show how elevation and bay influence change within the valley.
Grape guideMerlot

The grape name gives context. It is not a review of this bottle.

Getting to know Merlot.

Merlot is a red grape that can make a complete wine or soften a Cabernet-led blend. It generally ripens earlier than Cabernet Sauvignon and often has a rounder structure.

Category guide

What to expect in the glass

Regional guides describe plum and other red or dark fruit, with less forceful tannin than Cabernet Sauvignon in many examples. Climate and blending can make it fresh and medium-bodied or broader and richer.

Sources: New Zealand Winegrowers; Napa Valley Vintners. Checked Aug 10, 2026. See all 28 Merlot wines we cover →

Where this information comes from

Store listing
Price, package, product identifier, and shopper rating. Checked Aug 10, 2026.
Barcode
The shelf barcode shown here is computed from the store product identifier. It has not been checked against a bottle.
Method
Every price, rating and fact here is a dated observation. How we check.

Report a correction or bottle mismatch.